• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Pizza Cottage - Cozy Lancaster Pizza Restaurant with Flavorful Pies & Great Service

Pizza Cottage, located in Lancaster, Ohio, is a beloved pizza restaurant known for its cozy atmosphere and standout menu items like the All the Way Pizza, Chicken Garden Salad, and Fried Mozzarella. Customers praise its consistent quality, prompt service, and welcoming environment. The garlic butter accompaniment and signature dishes such as the BLT and Hawaiian pizzas highlight their thoughtful flavors. With additional treats like breadsticks and cheesy garlic bread, Pizza Cottage balances classic comfort with community charm. Whether dining in a quieter setting or grabbing carryout, it remains a reliable spot where flavorful, well-crafted pizzas shine.

Pizza Cottage at a glance

  • Address 1961 E Main St, Lancaster, OH 43130, United States
  • Phone +1 740-277-6289
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant , Chicken wings restaurant , Italian restaurant , Restaurant , Sports bar .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Pizza Cottage: Reviews & Ratings

Josh B
5

Great place to grab a pizza. Every time we have been I would say this is one of the quieter pizza shops to eat at in Lancaster.

Jessica Smith
5

This is my go-to pizza place in Lancaster. Great prices, always great service, foods always on time when I do carry out. And they never forget the garlic butter. 10/10.

Jeremy Hupp
5

As always, the pizza is amazing. Environment is great. The service is always fantastic. They have the best BLT pizza around.

jess frank
5

Best experience yet. Misty, from Eastside Pizza Cottage, is an amazing server! Food on point as usual. Tried the gyros pizza, it was okay. It needed more Tzatziki sauce for one thing the other you can't help... each piece should have the exact amount so you can taste it all together. Hawaiian was amazing, and the signature chef salad was phenomenal per usual. The East Side Pizza Cottage now serves alcoho and beer. No tap ... yet... Love this community staple.

Jenna bear
5

Service was excellent this evening. Shorthanded tonight, but waitress was super efficient.

Joe Roberts
5

Quite enjoyable. I had a quick vacation to Ohio and was wanting the old taste of Ohio style pizza. After going to the hometown pizza chain ,(Dona....) their pizza just wasn't the same as I remembered to trigger my memory of good Ohio pizza. I decided to give it another chance the next day and went to Pizza Cottage this time. Finally, finally my memery was satisfied. Service was great, taste was even better. Will be going again when I come back to town. Thank you Pizza Cottage for keeping that good pizza memory alive.

Jacob Stone
5

Just don't call orders in and you're good (they have an AI on the phone).

Mellow Aurality
5

Stopped here to check out the new location, and we were pleasantly surprised. This East side location is much nicer than the West side The updates are tasteful, the atmosphere is casual and fun, and the staff is friendly. We opted for the cauliflower crust pizza. It is one of the best we've tried! Baked just right: crispy-chewy and loaded with a good sauce-cheese-topping ratio. Definitely worth a repeat visit!!

Location

  • Pizza Cottage
    Pizza Cottage
    1961 E Main St, Lancaster, OH 43130, United States Hotline: +1 740-277-6289

Pizza Cottage, nestled at 1961 E Main St in Lancaster, Ohio, is a cherished local pizza restaurant that strikes the perfect balance between classic comfort food and a welcoming atmosphere. Known for its quiet dining experience and attentive service, this spot has earned a loyal following among pizza enthusiasts and casual diners alike.

The menu offers some standout options that truly define the Pizza Cottage experience. Their signature All the Way Pizza is a harmonious blend of fresh toppings, showcasing the kitchen’s dedication to quality and flavor. For those seeking something lighter, the Chicken Garden Salad provides a crisp and satisfying alternative.

Appetizer choices like Fried Mozzarella, Breadsticks, and the ever-popular Garlic Bread with Cheese (available for a small additional cost) make excellent starters or sharable bites. The garlic butter accompanying the dishes is a small but memorable touch, often highlighted by returning customers for enhancing the overall meal.

Regulars praise Pizza Cottage for its consistent excellence—whether it’s the flaky, well-crafted crust, or the carefully prepared specialty items such as the BLT pizza, which stands out as a unique and flavorful offering in the pizza category. The introduction of local favorites like the Hawaiian and the gyro pizza reflects a creative menu that respects tradition while inviting occasional culinary adventure.

Beyond the food, the service at Pizza Cottage consistently receives high marks. Servers like Misty exemplify the community spirit and efficiency that make dining here a pleasant experience, even during busy or understaffed times. The addition of alcohol and beer to the menu further enhances the laid-back vibe, positioning Pizza Cottage as not just a place to eat, but a communal spot to unwind.

In sum, Pizza Cottage offers more than just pizza; it delivers a dependable, flavorful meal paired with great service in a relaxed setting. Whether you're dining in or picking up a carryout, this Lancaster gem makes each visit feel like a comforting yet fresh experience.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Delivery
    • Drive-through
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards